EP275 GIF
In episode 275, Coffey talks with Amy McDowell and Sasha Vaikhman about resolving workplace conflict before it grows into a complaint, a resignation, or a lawsuit.
GMHRN BLOG
HR News items that caught our attention this week: 

1. Judge declines to block anti-DEI executive order for federal contractors.

2. EEOC chair signals scrutiny of unions and apprenticeship programs.

3. Why haven’t you retired? Railroad worker wins $1.6 million age-bias verdict against Norfolk Southern.

4. Restaurant to pay $3 million to settle sexual harassment suit involving teens.

5. 2ND CIRCUIT: Required pre-shift waiting time can be compensable under the FLSA.

6. AI-polished resumes are now recruiters’ top stressor.

7. UK civil servant on trial over five simultaneous government jobs.

The details and links are all listed below. But first, Mike’s take:

Since the beginning of the second Trump Administration, workplace diversity, equity, and inclusion programs have been in federal regulators’ crosshairs. The first two of this week’s articles are examples of this.

However, once the rhetoric from both sides of the DEI issue has been cleared, most of the Administration’s actions have primarily underscored existing law.

Take, for example, our first story about the President’s Executive Order from March of this year.

The EO prohibited federal contractors from engaging in “racially discriminatory DEI activities,” which the order defines as “disparate treatment based on race or ethnicity” in recruitment, employment, contracting, program participation or allocation of resources.

Well, duh. Of course that is illegal. Take out the hot-button letters “DEI” and the executive order becomes pretty generic.

But those three letters were included for a specific reason: to address the concern (supported by at least a few court decisions; see the 2025 Ames v. Ohio decision) that some DEI programs passed from expanding talent pools and ensuring equal opportunity to succeed to outright race or sex-based preferences and outcomes.

Were those excesses as widespread as some of the programs’ detractors claim?

Not in my experience. Most of the DEI programs I’ve encountered were focused on expanding the available talent pool through nontraditional outreach, removal of unnecessary proxies for competency, and implementing structured employee selection processes.

And in a good program, once a new employee was on board, the firm’s focus was to protect their investment in the new employee by providing an environment where they can do their best work.

It was just good business.

But there were, to use a technical term, whackadoodle DEI training programs that turned into struggle sessions where employees were expected to admit their privilege, were separated into groups by their immutable characteristics, or otherwise demeaned by facilitators because of their status in a protected class.

There were also instances where leadership set management and board-level representation quotas.

These were and are largely illegal under Title VII but, with a few exceptions, the EEOC and other regulators seemed to turn a blind eye to them in an effort to right past wrongs.

All of that leads us to the anti-DEI executive orders President Trump issued at the beginning of his second administration.

Because there was ambiguity about what “DEI” meant, politicians and social activists could easily talk past one another in decrying or advocating for the administration’s new anti-DEI policies. And when a term can mean anything, it means nothing.

Which is why I was glad to read the court’s opinion. It goes back to a black and white review of what conduct is legal and illegal under federal law.

Judge Abelson wrote that the EO clause banning “racially discriminatory DEI activities” alone “may very well have run afoul of the First Amendment,” because “DEI activities” is “far from self-explanatory.” However, the EO’s definition of those activities as “disparate treatment based on race or ethnicity” clearly constrained the scope of the Order.

So, while the court addressed fears that government agencies might use anti-DEI language to suppress organizations’ freedom of expression and noted where those would be illegal, the President’s Executive Order was left intact and, apparently, even the plaintiffs were satisfied with the court’s decision.

The takeaway for HR is as it has ever been. Know the law and, within its confines, act in the best interest of the company by creating processes to recruit and retain the best talent available. Remove unfair obstacles to employees’ success and advancement. Treat employees as individuals with dignity—not boxes to be checked.

All of this was true before anyone attached three letters to the conversation.

Be well, do good, and keep your chin up!

–COFFEY

Judge declines to block anti-DEI executive order for federal contractors

 

  • A federal judge in Maryland denied a preliminary injunction against Executive Order 14,398, the March 2026 order requiring a new anti-DEI clause in federal contracts.

     

  • The clause bars contractors from “racially discriminatory DEI activities,” which the order defines as “disparate treatment based on race or ethnicity” in recruitment, employment, contracting, program participation or allocation of resources.

     

  • In the complaint filed by the National Association of Diversity Officers in Higher Education and others, the plaintiffs claimed that the executive order “equates most mentions of ‘race or ethnicity’ to ‘racially discriminatory DEI activities.’ They argued ‘disparate treatment’ could sweep in lawful outreach, training and research.

     

  • Judge Abelson held that “disparate treatment” carries its settled legal meaning, intentional discrimination, so the order “only prohibits contractors from engaging in conduct that is already prohibited by federal law.”

     

  • Research on racial health disparities and teaching or publishing about DEI are not, on their own, barred by the EO, according to the court decision.

     

  • The government told the court that some DEI activity falls within the law and that a contract could not be canceled for discussing historical racial disparities.

     

  • Contractors penalized for lawful activity can still challenge that specific enforcement action in court, and the judge said such action could violate the First Amendment.

     

  • The plaintiff coalition said the order now “means nothing more than ‘follow the well-settled law.’

SHRM: EEOC chair signals scrutiny of unions and apprenticeship programs

 

 

  • EEOC Chair Andrea Lucas told an IBEW apprentice on X that the EEOC ‘has jurisdiction over unions and apprenticeships as well.’

     

  • The apprentice said an instructor told his class it was ‘the wrong minority group’ for available jobs.

     

  • Title VII covers labor organizations directly, including membership, referrals, apprenticeship admissions and grievance handling.

     

  • SHRM says Lucas’s comments do not establish a formal new enforcement initiative.

     

  • Lucas told Bloomberg Law the EEOC is ‘neither singling out nor ignoring any category of covered entity.’

     

  • A former EEOC general counsel said union discrimination never surfaced as a problem needing more agency resources.

Why haven’t you retired? Railroad worker wins $1.6 million age-bias verdict against Norfolk Southern

 

 

  • A federal jury found Norfolk Southern removed a 64-year-old railroad worker from service because of his age.

     

  • Jurors awarded about $794,000 in compensatory damages and found the violation willful, which doubles the award.

     

  • The court entered final judgment of about $1.59 million on Oct. 15.

     

  • He alleged a superintendent pulled him over injury concerns, and his own doctors cleared him to return.

     

  • Days before his 65th birthday the superintendent allegedly asked him why he had not retired.

     

  • The company’s medical department called him able to work, which blocked short-term disability benefits.

Restaurant to pay $3 million to settle sexual harassment suit involving teens

 

 

  • Il Fornaio will pay $3 million to resolve EEOC allegations of pervasive sexual harassment across its California and Nevada restaurants.

     

  • Many of the affected employees were teenagers, and the EEOC says it identified at least 100 women.

     

  • The EEOC alleged the company failed to act on complaints and retaliated against workers who raised them.

     

  • A three-year consent decree requires HR staff to take at least three hours of live, in-person training a year, and managers two hours.

     

  • The consent decree did not include an admission of guilt by Il Fornaio.

2ND CIRCUIT: Required pre-shift waiting time can be compensable under the FLSA

 

 

  • The Second Circuit revived a collective action against Lidl over unpaid time employees spent waiting to be let into the store.

     

  • Workers required to report at a set time and place are ‘engaged to wait’ and may be owed pay even before clocking in.

     

  • The court refused to treat roughly 15 unpaid minutes a week as too small to matter at the pleading stage.

     

  • One judge dissented, saying waiting outside was not integral to the employees’ principal duties.

     

  • The decision binds employers in New York, Connecticut and Vermont and sends the case back for further proceedings.

AI-polished resumes are now recruiters’ top stresso

 

 

  • 36% of recruiters say recruiting is more stressful than a year ago, down from 45% in 2025 and 54% in 2024.

     

  • Among those more-stressed recruiters, AI-polished resumes were the most-cited reason at 33%, the first time an AI-related reason has topped Employ’s 19-year Recruiter Nation survey.

     

  • They edged out not enough qualified candidates (30%), competition from other employers (27%) and candidate fraud (25%).

     

  • 27% of organizations reported confirmed AI-driven candidate fraud, up from 23% in 2025, and another 18% suspect it.

     

  • Among teams that saw confirmed or suspected fraud, half estimated they received more than 50 fraudulent applications.

     

  • The most common fraud was falsified skills, credentials or employment history (37%), followed by fake references or identity masquerading (34%) and AI-fabricated resumes (31%).

     

  • 19% said they suspected state-sponsored or foreign operatives among applicants.

     

  • Background checks are the most common response to fraud (43%), followed by in-person interviews (35%) and email, phone or device verification (34%).

     

  • 54% of teams now use background checks and 48% use identity verification tools, both ahead of screening and assessment tools (41%).

     

  • 66% say AI made their jobs easier, but only 18% say more than half their time has shifted to higher-value work, down from 26% in 2025.

     

  • 47% have formal guidelines for recruiters’ use of AI and 44% for candidates’ use. The share with recruiter guidelines in place or in development fell from 87% to 77%.

     

  • Zogby Analytics surveyed more than 1,200 U.S. recruiters and HR managers for Employ, which sells recruiting software, in August 2026. Small businesses made up 55% of this year’s sample versus 32% in 2025, which affects year-over-year comparisons.

UK civil servant on trial over five simultaneous government jobs

 

 

  • 36% of recruiters sa

     

  • Prosecutors allege a 55-year-old civil servant earned almost 350,000 pounds from eight public employers while holding overlapping roles.

     

  • By May 2023 he allegedly held five full-time jobs at once, with contracts totalling 183 hours a week.

     

  • He denies nine counts of fraud, the trial is ongoing, and none of the allegations has been proven.

     

  • He allegedly cited caring for an unwell mother to justify working from home across the roles.

     

  • The case surfaced through a government payroll data-matching programme, not an employer’s own monitoring.

     

  • A 2025 Cifas survey of 2,000 workers found 19 percent of UK employees admitted secretly holding two competing jobs.