EP277 GIF FOR TAZ

In episode 277, Coffey talks with Jeremy York about leader roles moving from managing tasks to building the trust-based relationships that drive engagement and retention.

EP277 Thursday Brief banner

Welcome to the Thursday News Brief. Here are some articles that caught our attention this week:

1. SHRM–Fidelity: Younger workers prize job security that HR underrates.

2. Gallup: U.S. engagement drops to 29%, lowest since 2011.

3. Court: “Karen” comment does not make a race-bias case.

4. LinkedIn: Only 1.2% of users list AI-literacy skills; they are more likely to be hired or promoted.

5. Gartner: Boards expect AI savings that almost no organization is delivering.

6. HBR: Employees override good AI because accountability never moved.

7.  Sixth Circuit: IT project manager exempt from overtime; DOL test upheld.

8. EEOC: Field offices cut charge-response time to 15 days.

9. EEOC: Smithfield pays $245,000 after refusing a pregnant worker’s accommodation requests.

The details and links are all listed below. But first, Mike’s take:

I am writing this on Tuesday morning. If you are reading it, this evening’s election results didn’t result in (immediate) Armageddon, so we’ve got that going for us.

A SHRM-Fidelity study was released last month suggesting that HR leaders’ understanding of what younger workers value doesn’t track what those younger workers say they actually value.

For example, 85% of younger workers rated job security as very or extremely important; only 27% of HR leaders thought it mattered to them. 

But what people actually value changes through the employment life cycle.

  • For instance, in the SHRM-Fidelity study, the top five job features younger worker’s rated as very or extremely important were:
  • a fair and respectful environment (86%)
  • job security (85%)
  • work/life balance (80%)
  • a good manager relationship (80%)
  • clarity about job responsibilities (77%)

What’s not there? Pay.

But the same report says that “pay was the most commonly reported factor influencing younger workers’ decisions to change jobs.”

The study doesn’t say this directly, but I read it as the difference between why people stay and why they leave.

The lesson I see here for employers is to remember the three hats you will wear in the employee lifecycle: recruiter, employer, and the place they used to work.

My experience is that, regardless of age, job seekers are primarily looking for a role that will pay well and, secondarily, meet their lifestyle and professional growth ambitions. Everything else being roughly the same, pay carries the day.

Once they are onboard, the employer’s objective is to maximize their performance. That boils down to culture, trust, investment, and recognition—giving them an environment where they happily bring their best every day.

The day an employee’s alarm goes off and they think, “Crap, I have to do that job today” you aren’t getting that person’s best effort.

That’s where the study’s top five belong: This is where we focus to keep people.

Finally, with rare exceptions, most of your employees will one day leave you. Sometimes, that day arrives earlier than necessary because they aren’t engaged in their current role (see the top five above) and a different opportunity that pays more money begins to sound more attractive.

The SHRM-Fidelity study indicated that only 45% of younger workers say their current pay meets their needs (against 53% of experienced workers), and only 40% think it will let them reach their life goals (against 50%). If we’re being honest, roughly half of all workers, regardless of time in the workforce, say their pay falls short.

If people need more money to live the lives they want, they are going to seriously consider another job that pays better.

So my not-so-hot take is that an employer needs to have an all-of-the-above approach. Definitely pay your people fairly. But beyond that, give your frontline leaders the tools, training, and freedom to meet each employee’s unique needs while still holding them accountable for performance.

While studies like this give us some insight on macro demographic trends, don’t treat your employees as generalizations. Each person, whatever demographic groups they belong to, is an individual. Meet them there and focus leaders’ efforts on incentivizing and supporting them as unique people with unique needs.

Be well, do good, and keep your chin up!

–COFFEY

SHRM–Fidelity: Younger workers prize job security that HR underrates

 

  • HR leaders underestimate how much younger workers value job security and core benefits, SHRM–Fidelity research finds.

     

  • Job security: 85% of workers ages 18–26 rate it very or extremely important; only 27% of HR leaders think it is for them.

     

  • HR leaders overestimate interest in remote work (70% vs. 42%) and underestimate in-person work (7% vs. 59%).

     

  • 61% of younger workers are AI avoiders or light users, but only 4% of HR leaders associate AI resistance with Gen Z.

     

  • HR leaders attribute pay demands to unrealistic expectations (84%) and entitlement (67%); younger workers cite cost of living (75%) and housing (71%).

     

  • Skills development matters to 73% of younger workers; HR leaders put it at 47%.

    Gallup: U.S. engagement drops to 29%, lowest since 2011

     

    • U.S. employee engagement fell to 29% in the third quarter of 2026, the lowest Gallup has recorded since 2011.

       

    • Actively disengaged workers rose to 18% and 53% were not engaged.

       

    • Engagement fell five points among fully remote employees and two among hybrid, against about one point on-site.

       

    • The share who strongly agree they know what is expected of them fell three points to 46%, ten below its 2015 high.

       

    • The share who feel someone at work cares about them fell from 40% to 37%, against a 47% peak in March 2020.

       

    • Gallup counts each point as about 1.6 million workers — roughly 11 million fewer engaged since 2020.

    Court: “Karen” comment does not make a race-bias case

     

    • A White school psychologist sued her Long Island school district, alleging race and disability discrimination and retaliation. She said administrators defended a secretary who called her “Karen” and then failed to protect her after she complained. 
    • A federal judge in New York granted summary judgment to the district on all of her federal claims. 
    • The court found no adverse employment action and no severe or pervasive hostile environment. 
    • Her federal claims were dismissed with prejudice, and her state-law claims were sent back to state court. 

    LinkedIn: Only 1.2% of users list AI-literacy skills; they are more likely to be hired or promoted

     

    • LinkedIn analyzed its platform data on members, job postings and skills to see how AI is changing which workers get hired and promoted.

       

    • Members who list AI-literacy skills on their profiles are 78% more likely to be hired and 11% more likely to be promoted than members who don’t.

       

    • Employers are asking for these skills more often: the share of LinkedIn job postings requiring AI literacy has grown roughly 65%. LinkedIn states the time frame two ways in the same release, once as the past 12 months and once as each of the past two years.

       

    • Few workers list the skills so far: only 1.2% of LinkedIn members have an AI skill on their profile.

       

    • In the U.S., workers with AI skills move into occupations paying an average of $28,000 more than the occupations workers without them enter.

       

    • LinkedIn published no methodology. These figures show a correlation between listing AI skills and getting hired, not proof that adding the skills causes it.

     

    Gartner: Boards expect AI savings that almost no organization is delivering

     

    • Gartner finds three-quarters of board members expect AI to deliver productivity and cost savings, but 97% of organizations can’t hit savings goals through productivity alone.

       

    • Only 21% of the time AI frees up is being redirected into more innovative work, from a survey of 1,865 employees.

       

    • Thirty-eight percent of companies are over budget on AI and 85% plan to spend more next year.

       

    • In a July survey of 297 CHROs, 78% said leaders have no alignment on where AI creates value.

       

    • A Gartner analyst says the problem is not creating capacity but making it usable.

    HBR: Employees override good AI because accountability never moved

     

    • HBS’s Das Narayandas argues companies deploy AI faster than they redesign the governance around it, so systems stay permanent advisers.

       

    • His opening case: a global bank’s AI credit system beat humans in pilots, but six months later most files still went through human review and temporary safeguards had become permanent steps.

       

    • When accountability does not move with authority, employees keep overriding the system to protect themselves.

       

    • Real adoption reallocates authority explicitly: who or what decides, who explains, and who absorbs the risk.

       

    • Amazon’s “Hands off the Wheel” separated input authority from output authority, shifting vendor managers to auditing inputs, exceptions and outcomes.

       

    • His test: if the system were turned off tomorrow, would the decisions that matter change? If not, adoption has not occurred.

    Sixth Circuit: IT project manager exempt from overtime; DOL test upheld

     

    • Most employees must get overtime for hours over 40. The FLSA exempts some computer employees whose main job is designing, developing, documenting, testing or modifying computer systems, if they earn at least $27.63 an hour.

       

    • Loren Bennink built Cincinnati Bell’s automated customer phone system for years as a contractor. Cincinnati Bell then hired him in 2016, classified him as exempt and paid him a flat $3,000 a week however many hours he worked.

       

    • He sued for overtime and for $75 an hour for every hour worked. He argued that his main duty, documenting how the phone system routed calls, was “little more than creating ‘complicated flowcharts.’”

       

    • The court disagreed and held that he was exempt. It said his documentation was what let the company understand and change the system, and that the law requires no particular degree or job title.

       

    • Since the Supreme Court ended deference to agencies in 2024, courts no longer have to follow DOL’s interpretations. The court did its own analysis and concluded that DOL’s “primary duty” test “gets it right.”

    EEOC: Field offices cut charge-response time to 15 days

     

    • Law firms report that many EEOC field offices now want position statements in 15 days rather than 30.

       

    • Extensions are reportedly limited to one, of 7 to 10 days, and some offices deny them.

       

    • An EEOC spokesperson told Bloomberg Law there is no official agency-wide policy change.

       

    • Some employers that answered on day 16 reportedly received cause findings.

    EEOC: Smithfield pays $245,000 after refusing a pregnant worker’s accommodation requests

     

    • Smithfield Fresh Meats runs the world’s largest pork processing plant, in Tar Heel, N.C. A newly hired employee there told the company she was pregnant shortly after she started.

       

    • After a workplace accident, she developed pregnancy complications, gave Smithfield her medical restrictions and asked for a reasonable accommodation.

       

    • Smithfield allegedly told her it “does not provide pregnancy accommodations” and fired her.

       

    • The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act requires employers to accommodate known pregnancy-related limitations unless doing so causes undue hardship. The EEOC sued after failing to settle through its conciliation process.

       

    • Smithfield will pay $245,000 under a two-year consent decree. It must also put in place procedures for receiving and processing PWFA accommodation requests, train managers and HR on the law, and report periodically to the EEOC.

       

    • The EEOC’s regional attorney said the case shows employers need policies, training and oversight so managers know which accommodations the law requires.